أوان التحقيق وليس التحريض - فهمي هويدي

أوان التحقيق وليس التحريض
 

منذ وقعت جريمة قتل ثلاثين جنديا وضابطا في سيناء، ونحن نسمع أصوات المحرضين والمزايدين بأكثر من أصوات الباحثين والمحققين.
 فالأولون لديهم إجابات جاهزة في الموضوع (وفي كل موضوع آخر)،  في حين أن الاخيرين يسألون أكثر مما يجيبون ويتأنون في إصدار الأحكام والتقييمات، حتى تتوافر لديهم المعلومات الصحيحة والمقنعة.
ولا مفر من الاعتراف بأن حظوظ الأولين أكبر في زماننا.
 ذلك انهم رهن الإشارة في كل مناسبة، وحاضرون في مختلف منابر الإعلام وبرامجه في أي وقت، خصوصا ان بعضهم لا يكاد يذكر أو ترى له صور إلا في الملمات.
كأنما صاروا فريقا متعدد الاختصاصات جاهزا للقيام بالواجب عند اللزوم.
الأمر الذي يذكرنا بمكاتب توريد المجموعات المعروفة في المحيط الفني.
وهي التي لديها طواقم جاهزة توفر الحشود المطلوبة لأي مشهد، سواء كان حربا أو عرسا أو جنازة حتى استعراضا عسكريا.
قرأت ان نشاط تلك المكاتب تطور في ألمانيا، بحيث ظهر منها جيل جديد مستعد لتنظيم المظاهرات لصالح أو ضد أي قضية عامة من الاجهاض والشذوذ الجنسي إلى الاتفاق النووي مع إيران والدفاع عن الأكراد.
وفي هذه الحالة فإن المكتب المختص يتعاقد على الموضوع، فيحشد المتظاهرين ويجهز اللافتات والهتافات والهتيفة، لعدد معين من الساعات مقابل أجر معلوم.
ما ان وقعت الواقعة يوم الجمعة الماضي.
حتى انتشرت المجموعات في مختلف المنابر الإعلامية، وشرع أفرادها في ممارسة التعبئة والتحريض وتوزيع الاتهامات،  الأمر الذي دفعني إلى تسجيل ثلاث ملاحظات هي: ترددت في تحليلات وتعليقات المتحدثين فكرة مبسطة خلاصتها ان الإرهابيين بالجريمة التي ارتكبوها وبالممارسات الأخرى التي لجأوا إليها انما أرادوا «إسقاط الدولة المصرية».
 وهو مصطلح يثير عندي رد فعل سريع يدفعني إلى القول ان الذين يطلقون هذا الكلام يخطئون مرتين، فهم من ناحية لا يعرفون حجم قوة ورسوخ الدولة المصرية التي تمتد جذورها في عمق البيئة والمجتمع منذ أكثر من خمسة آلاف سنة، الأمر الذي يوفر لها قدرا هائلا من الثبات يجعلها عصية على الإسقاط الذي يتوهمه أو يروج له هؤلاء.
من ناحية ثانية فإنهم يختزلون الدولة في الحكومة وأحيانا في شخص الرئيس (مصر مبارك مثلا)  وذلك اختزال مخل لأن الدولة كل والحكومة جزء، والأولى تتكون من الشعب والأرض والمؤسسات في حين ان الحكومة هى إحدى تلك المؤسسات.
وأرجح أن الترويج لفكرة استهداف اسقاط الدولة يمثل مبالغة متعددة للتهويل من شأن الخطر، وتجنب تصنيف الإرهاب باعتباره وسيلة شريرة للصراع ضد الحكومة.
كان واضحا في خطاب المتحدثين إلحاحهم على الضيق بالديمقراطية والحث على التشدد والقمع بأكثر من دعوتهم إلى محاولة تفهم ملابسات الحدث الذي تكرر أكثر من مرة.
 ان شئت فقل ان التعليقات توسلت بالعضلات وليس بالعقل.
فمن المتحدثين من دعا إلى إزالة مساكن السيناويين عند الشريط الحدودي باعتبارهم حاضنين للإرهاب ومنهم من دعا إلى إعلان حالة الطوارئ والتوسع في المحاكمات العسكرية مع عدم التدقيق في مسألة حقوق الإنسان.
ومنهم من طالب بتأجيل الانتخابات إلى ما بعد القضاء على الإرهاب، ومنهم من تشدد في الابقاء على قانون منع التظاهر وعدم الاستجابة لضغوط سحبه أو تعديله، وفي هذا السياق حبذ البعض فكرة «الشرطة المجتمعية» التي بمقتضاها يتحول نصف المواطنين إلى شرطة والنصف الآخر إلى مخبرين.
وفي حين تبنى الخطاب لغة التشدد والقمع فإن أحدا لم يطرح السؤال: لماذا تكررت حوادث قتل الجنود في سيناء وكيف نضمن عدم تكرارها؟ الملاحظة الثالثة وثيقة الصلة بالثانية، وخلاصتها ان التحليلات صوبت النظر إلى الخارج بأكثر مما صوبته إلى الداخل.
بمعنى انها انشغلت بما يدبره الآخرون أو يتمنونه، ولم تنشغل سواء بالتحقيق فيما جرى أو بما كان يتعين علينا ان نفعله للحيلولة دون وقوع ما جرى، وهو نهج في التفكير ليس جديدا لأن استسهال الإحالة إلى اتهام الخارج (الذي نعرف انه ليس بريئا دائما) أمر درجنا عليه، في غيبة ثقافة نقد الذات فضلا عن تراجع قيمة المساءلة في المجال العام.
حين وقعت تفجيرات لندن في عام 2005 التي هزت المجتمع البريطاني وراح ضحيتها أكثر من خمسين شخصا، فإن أجهزة السلطة لم توجه أصابع الاتهام إلى أي أحد خلال الأسبوع الأول من الجريمة، ولم تطلق اي تصريحات بخصوص المتهمين إلا بعدما استجوبت بعض المشتبهين الذين تم اعتقالهم، ثم حددت سبعة أشخاص وجهت إليهم الاتهام.
وهؤلاء قدموا إلى محاكمة علنية استمرت نحو سنتين، وأسفرت عن إدانة أربعة حكم عليهم بالسجن المؤبد في حين تمت تبرئة الثلاثة الآخرين، الشاهد ان الأمر عولج بغير تشنج أو ترهيب أو قمع لعموم المسلمين ذوي الأصول الباكستانية الذين يعيشون في بريطانيا.
إنني اتفهم جيدا حساسية الموقف وخصوصية وضع اطرافه، لكنني أزعم أننا إذا لم نستوعب دروس الحدث فسوف ترتكب جريمة أخرى.
وستكون الأخيرة أفدح لأنها ستتم في صمت بعيدا عن علم أو رقابة الرأي العام، بما قد يفتح الباب لتكرار ما جرى مرة أخرى.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

تاريخ النشر :- Oct 27 2014

تعليقات القراء




Bruno:

A packet of envelopes http://www.optimum.ie/momentum/prism-international-sales-and-marketing-lmx14/ buy generic albendazole Some examples cited by prosecutors: an SAC job candidate whoshared a house in the Hamptons with the chief financial officerof a large publicly traded industrial company; a portfoliomanager who allegedly traded on inside information he said hehad received from "a friend of my cousin" who worked in thefinance department of Dell Inc ; and an analyst who hada "buddy" who happened to be a "senior guy at Microsoft."

2015 ,25 Nov

Gavin:

Have you seen any good films recently? http://www.optimum.ie/momentum/prism-international-sales-and-marketing-lmx14/ buy mebendazole albendazole The Wolverine actor revealed his secret to getting that bulging and cut look for the screen. A 6000 calorie-a-day diet of boiled chicken and a 30 hour dehydration before guzzling down a glycerin and honey (or Coke) mixture to make his veins pop and his muscles bulge for those fight scenes!

2015 ,25 Nov

Rodrick:

I'm at Liverpool University http://www.acrissul.com.br/noticias order flovent online The latest problem involves water that accumulated over the last month since the operator, Tokyo Electric Power Co., began creating the chemical barrier to stop underground leaks after detecting radiation spikes in water samples in May.

2015 ,25 Nov

Graham:

I like it a lot http://www.optimum.ie/momentum/prism-international-sales-and-marketing-lmx14/ albendazole 400 mg chewable PetroChina Co. and Kunlun Energy Co. (135) rebounded fromyesterday’s plunge after PetroChina said it would ensure itssubsidiary’s stability amid antigraft investigations. PetroChinagained 1.8 percent to HK$8.42 and Kunlun rose 2.6 percent toHK$11.16.

2015 ,25 Nov

Billie:

I'd like to change some money http://www.pharafina.com/innovation albendazole api price "The next crisis is going to involve not just Europe and the United States, but India and Brazil and China," said former senator Chris Dodd, speaking generally about serious threats that can spring from anywhere in an increasingly global financial system. "What happens in one corner of the world, particularly in significant economies, affects everybody."

2015 ,25 Nov

Jane:

Insert your card http://www.pharafina.com/innovation albendazole prescription drugs Martin, 47, said that after freeing himself, he got clear of the coffin and tracked it as it fell to the ground, just as he did when he first pulled off the stunt 25 years ago on just his 17th skydive.

2015 ,23 Nov

Edwardo:

I'd like , please http://www.optimum.ie/momentum/prism-international-sales-and-marketing-lmx14/ purchase albenza online The figures followed strong euro zone and U.S. businesssurveys the previous day, suggesting a global economic recoverymight be gaining traction. That prompted investors to cutexposure to low-risk debt, pushing yields up.

2015 ,23 Nov

Antione:

Thanks funny site http://www.pharafina.com/innovation albendazole albenza Two  questions need to be answered, the first one being how high the temperatures will increase  along with the rising carbon dioxide levels; the second being how much of the global warming has been caused by the natural variability compared to human greenhouse emissions.

2015 ,23 Nov

Carol:

It's serious http://www.optimum.ie/momentum/prism-international-sales-and-marketing-lmx14/ zentel 200 mg albendazole "Unfortunately, we believe the modifications to the ratesfiled by Aetna and Coventry would not allow us to collect enoughpremiums to cover the cost of the plans, including the medicalnetwork and service expectations of our customers," Aetna saidin the letter to insurance commissioner Therese Goldsmith.

2015 ,23 Nov

Felix:

Would you like a receipt? http://www.irondalecafe.com/history/ actos pioglitazone Denmark added a debt ceiling to its laws in the 1990s as a constitutional waiver to allow the transfer of the day-to-day responsibilities for the national debt from the Ministry of Finance to Denmark's independent central bank, Kirkegaard says.

2015 ,23 Nov

John:

Would you like a receipt? http://updatecontent.com/service/ avanafil cost But other Sinhalese were murdering, rooting out Tamils by showing them objects and demanding to know the Sinhala word. A young Sinhalese artist, Chandraguptha Thenuwara, recalls his bus being stopped.

2015 ,21 Nov

Andrew:

I'm doing a masters in law http://carissaphelps.com/training/ order stendra Kaine said Reid is considering offering an amendment thatwould provide only enough funding to keep the governmentoperating through Nov. 15, instead of the Dec. 15 date containedin the House-passed bill.

2015 ,21 Nov

Willy:

Could you give me some smaller notes? http://carissaphelps.com/training/ where to buy avanafil/extendra "Since they have the highest growth expectations, it will be especially important for the market that they live up to those expectations," said Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist for Standard & Poor's Equity Research Services in New York. "Those results will be pivotal."

2015 ,21 Nov

Damian:

Have you got any qualifications? http://www.experimentalconversations.com/issue/spring-2013/ steal trazodone online For the first time foreigners will be permitted to invest inprojects exploring non-traditional national gas resources, suchas shale gas and sea-bottom natural gas, but only viajoint-ventures with Chinese partners.

2015 ,21 Nov

Jimmie:

I'd like , please http://www.cherihelms.com/online-portfolio/ priligy cost TOKYO, Oct 18 (Reuters) - Japan's Mitsui Life Insurance hassuspended a plan to increase its stockpile of foreign bondsbecause it expects the value of U.S. bonds to fall as theFederal Reserve moves toward scaling back its economic stimuluslater in the year.

2015 ,20 Nov

Broderick:

I hate shopping http://www.thepennyloafers.com/portfolio/amanda-triglia/ order eriacta Lady Gaga isn't going to let a head injury slow her down. The "Edge of Glory" singer took to Twitter on June 11, 2012 to update fans on her condition after she was struck on the head by a pole while performing in concert in New Zealand the previous night. "Thank you so much for all the thoughtful messages," Gaga, 26, wrote. "I feel a bit woozy but a little better everyday. Very happy to be in beautiful Australia."

2015 ,20 Nov

Thomas:

I'm not sure http://www.all-tech-mechanical.com/cooling-services/ clomiphene 100 mg NEW DELHI, Aug 12 (Reuters) - India's Essar Power plans tolift coal imports by a fifth after converting plants currentlyusing gas, but the move is unlikely to signal a broader switchto coal by the nation's utilities in response to gas shortagesand price reforms.

2015 ,20 Nov

Bryon:

I'm not sure http://www.thepennyloafers.com/portfolio/amanda-triglia/ cheap eriacta Crawford's playoff run followed the Blackhawks' dominant regular season as he and Ray Emery shared the William M. Jennings Trophy for lowest team goals-against average. Included was an NHL-record 21-0-3 start.

2015 ,20 Nov

Stacey:

How do you do? http://clickandcreate.us/about/ generic vermox Officials in both Orissa and Andhra Pradesh have been stockpiling emergency food supplies and setting up shelters. The Indian military has put some of its forces on alert, and has trucks, transport planes and helicopters at the ready for relief operations.

2015 ,20 Nov

Cooler111:

I'm not interested in football http://www.6folds.com/portfolio/ abilify generic It is a scorching hot day as I stand on the corner of Oyster Street, just a few feet from the communal toilet in which the toddlers were found dead. But it is a chilling feeling looking around the shanty town, with its unpaved roads with black sewer water running down the middle, and thinking that somewhere here lives a child murderer.

2015 ,20 Nov

Fermin:

International directory enquiries http://www.euniceproductions.com/pixelmaniacs/ dapoxetine for sale * The U.S. and Iran held their highest-level talks in 36years on Thursday, in what some officials present described as asubstantial meeting over Tehran's disputed nuclear program thatcould begin to counter decades of enmity. ()

2015 ,20 Nov

Felton:

Where do you live? http://www.euniceproductions.com/pixelmaniacs/ dapoxetine 30mg USA TODAY's story "revealed an alarming number of cases involving unscrupulous and dishonest employees of nursing homes who siphoned, forged, and swindled millions of dollars from the trust fund accounts of unsuspecting and helpless residents," Nelson wrote. He requested that the IG examine "management and oversight" of the trust funds and "recommend corrective actions for any shortcomings."

2015 ,20 Nov

Jacob:

Accountant supermarket manager http://www.6folds.com/portfolio/ abilify coupon Pallone and Booker, as well as Rep. Rush Holt, will face off in the Democratic primary in August and the special election will take place in October.  The Holt campaigns did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

2015 ,20 Nov

Ronnie:

I'd like to apply for this job http://www.pivotmarine.com/maritime-consultancy megalis 10 mg price "From a tax planning perspective, don't skip out on having kids," Frank says. In fact, he says his daughter, now 21, saved his finances back when she was born. At the time, her birth (and status as a dependent) allowed him to qualify for the earned income tax credit, which was $3,000. "It changed my life," says Frank, who adds that most people who qualify for the earned income tax credit don't take it. (Low- to moderate-income working taxpayers are eligible.)

2015 ,20 Nov

Barney:

Please call back later http://www.azurrestaurant.com/index.php/about yagara cap Mr Cridland said that politically-charged attacks on the amount of corporation tax that some firms pay were sending the wrong message about encouraging businesses to flourish and were a threat to jobs.

2015 ,19 Nov

Brendon:

What university do you go to? http://www.azurrestaurant.com/index.php/about yagara Shares in Yancoal closed 4.3 percent higher at A$0.73 butwere far off Yanzhou's proposed purchase price of A$0.91 - aprice that values Yancoal at A$905 million ($825 million). Hitby a slide in coal prices, Yancoal's stock has lost around halfits value since its listing in June 2012.

2015 ,19 Nov

Lesley:

I'm sorry, he's http://michigansportscenter.com/about where can you buy hydrochlorothiazide Kate, who chose a bespoke cornflower blue crepe de chine Jenny Packham dress for the occasion, said: "It's very emotional. It's such a special time. I think any parent will know what this feeling feels like." Her husband agreed: "It's very special."

2015 ,19 Nov

Malik:

We went to university together http://iomhockfest.com/next-year/ ciprofloxacin online pharmacy Constructed in the Thirties on a rocky outcrop above Porthcurno Bay, the Minack Theatre's dramatic location has drawn visitors for generations. The theatre's summer season runs until September 29, with highlights including The Marriage of Figaro (July 15-19) by the New Cornwall Opera, and the Taming of the Shrew (September 9-13) by Shakespeare's Globe on tour.

2015 ,19 Nov

Rhett:

I'm from England http://www.fitspeakers.com/bookus.htm cheap motilium "The king was never informed - in any way or at any time - of the seriousness of the abject crimes of which the person concerned was convicted," a statement released by the royal palace said on Sunday.

2015 ,19 Nov

Gerry:

We're at university together http://www.orkesterjournalen.com/jazzbiografier coupons for cymbalta Mr Abbott said: "I hate to carp. Mr Rudd has just said you can't walk away from a price on carbon, but that's precisely what you did Kevin in April of 2010 ... It's one of the reasons why you lost the prime ministership."

2015 ,19 Nov

Felton:

Whereabouts are you from? http://www.puntocomsistemas.es/tpv-toledo-ayd estrace 0.5 mg Celebrities may look phenomenal on the red carpet, but they also have hordes of makeup artists at the ready for even the tiniest of touchups. Catch them without the thick layers of powder, smoky eyesh...

2015 ,19 Nov

Antonia:

I'm retired http://www.orkesterjournalen.com/jazzbiografier cymbalta xr NASA's Cassini spacecraft is poised to snap a dramatic portrait of Earth Friday, capturing a mosaic showing humanity's home in space as a pinprick of light just to one side of Saturn's spectacular rings.

2015 ,19 Nov

Kyle:

Could you tell me my balance, please? http://documentaforum.de/vorstand/ tamsulosin hydrochloride tablets Early versions of the measure introduced in June prohibited open-air testing of experimental pesticides and genetically modified crops, established a permitting process for the industry and placed a temporary moratorium on the expansion of GMO crop test fields.

2015 ,19 Nov

Maurice:

I hate shopping http://www.english-school.com.pl/index.php/lektorzy purchase domperidone Since the Budget, the 10-year gilt rate has jumped from 1.827pc to 2.272pc. The small rise will add £1bn to the UK’s £50bn of debt interest costs next year and £2bn in 2015 compared with the Government’s central forecast in March, analysis of the Office for Budget Responsibility’s data shows.

2015 ,19 Nov

Winston:

Looking for work http://www.bijouteriegolaz.com/bijoux.html neurontin 400 mg gabapentina "Based on the issues the federal marketplace is having today, we, too, do not have accessibility to enroll individuals," said chief executive John Adair. He said he believed the situation could continue until late October and called the government's IT performance "disappointing at best."

2015 ,19 Nov

Hershel:

I'm originally from Dublin but now live in Edinburgh http://bbgrocerymeatdeli.com/web-specials/ doxycycline buy online Russia follows Britain in beefing up the regulatory role ofits central bank while, as part of a broader trend, the EuropeanCentral Bank will start to oversee system-critical banks in theeuro zone next year.

2015 ,19 Nov

Conrad:

I'm retired http://www.tu-braunschweig-isl.de/LANDSCHAFTSARCHITEKTUR/ diflucan treatment Decisions on what type of contraception to use and how birth control choices might affect mental health are critical issues for young women, yet there has been very little research into "this intersection of family planning and psychiatric disorders," Keyes said.

2015 ,19 Nov

Pablo:

I'll call back later http://www.vaimnemaailm.ee/index.php/tegevused endep 50mg In a statement after the staff meetings, it added: "The company made it clear that rejection of change would result in closure. Regrettably, the union advised union members to reject any form of change.

2015 ,19 Nov

William:

I do some voluntary work http://www.vaimnemaailm.ee/index.php/tegevused order endep online Rivera, now 23, was 17 when he was arrested a few days after the shooting. Defense attorneys said Florida Department of Law Enforcement agents ambushed him near his home and held him until he confessed to killing Taylor.

2015 ,19 Nov

Joseph:

I went to http://www.tu-braunschweig-isl.de/LANDSCHAFTSARCHITEKTUR/ buy diflucan no prescription fast delivery "We've seen in the past that a lot of things can happen," Vettel said, referring to Sergio Perez's second place last year from 12th on the grid. "Race pace is very important, but today we did our homework."

2015 ,19 Nov

Louie:

I like watching football http://bh-studios.com/about-bh-studios cipralex medicamento pre㦿 A gallery assistant who Orquin said witnessed the attack immediately alerted the police. Orquin says police are confident about finding the culprits since one left his face uncovered and might have been caught on camera.

2015 ,19 Nov

Pedro:

A staff restaurant http://allstarbreakfast.com/award/ order misoprostol online Also Friday, an Ohio amusement park's thrill ride malfunctioned when a boat accidentally rolled backward down a hill and flipped over in water, injuring all seven people on it. Operators stopped the Shoot the Rapids water ride after the accident, said officials with Cedar Point amusement park in Sandusky, Ohio.

2015 ,19 Nov

Margarito:

Some First Class stamps http://kelvincruickshank.com/workshops/ where can i buy amoxicillin online Tomorrow sees the first Manchester derby of the season. The police have asked city centre supermarkets not to sell alcohol before or during the football match. I find this ironic, given how important alcohol marketing is to football and its coverage.

2015 ,19 Nov

Walter:

Is there ? http://www.chocolatepoker.rs/informacije/najbolji-poker-softver/ purchase arcoxia "The heroic efforts of their brother, Reece, to rescue Holly, Ella and Jordan from the fire also led to the tragic loss of his own life. This act of bravery is in stark contrast to the cowardice shown by Dyson Allen, who has attempted to evade responsibility for his actions throughout the investigation and the trial.

2015 ,19 Nov

Marcus:

I want to report a http://www.jubileusul.org.br/nota/833 benoquin cream for sale The deal is worth about half of Eurotech's market value andthe Italian company said it will use the money for investmentand the development of strategic products such as pervasive andlow-power computers, as well as possible acquisitions.

2015 ,19 Nov

Wesley:

I'd like to cancel a cheque http://kelvincruickshank.com/workshops/ 500mg amoxicillin "The way the sport is now and the way the testing is, it is so, so strict. Each rider has a blood passport where almost on a monthly basis, readings are taken," Froome said in an interview with Reuters TV the day after his triumph.

2015 ,19 Nov

Allan:

Get a job http://www.chocolatepoker.rs/informacije/najbolji-poker-softver/ order arcoxia "The company printed another robust set of numbers. Weexpect consensus estimates (for full-year results) to be revisedup by around 1-2 percent this morning," Nomura analyst GuillaumeDelmas wrote in a note.

2015 ,19 Nov

Benny:

Directory enquiries http://529easy.com/?page_id=8 apcalis sx thailand Schimel has been making the rounds on Wall Street and beyond to raise money, but despite his long history in the industry, he too is offering some fee cuts. Early investors will pay lower management and performance fees, the letter said.

2015 ,18 Nov

Earle:

What are the hours of work? http://www.bestiario.com/letras/ robaxin 750 Vinocur said he tried to work with Bonet at first, but was put off when the man threatened him. He said he alerted the SCRIE agency when neighbors complained about the rowdy behavior. The landlord said the city agency, which falls under the Department of Finance, didn’t want to hear it.

2015 ,18 Nov

Roberto:

Accountant supermarket manager http://529easy.com/?page_id=8 apcalis paypal Using technologies that offer anonymity - Tor for anonymous browsing, PGP for encrypted communications and untraceable currency Bitcoin - Silk Road has operated openly since January 2011. It would be easy to view the capture of Ulbricht and the closure of Silk Road as proof that anonymity on the internet is a fantasy.

2015 ,18 Nov